Regretsy, People of Walmart, similar

I’ve been appalled lately at the popularity of sites like Regretsy and People of Walmart. Websites whose sole purpose seems to be to make fun of other people, in a very personal way, by singling them out for public ridicule. Like one might do in 7th grade or something.

I will admit, some things on Etsy are appalling. But some things that Regretsy makes fun of are just simply things that don’t appeal to the owner of Regretsy – that doesn’t make them horrible. I browsed today while pondering this post, and found the author making fun of a Faerie hoodie – and also of the spelling “faerie.” Now, I’m not in that community, but it is my understanding that Faerie is a perfectly acceptable spelling (spellcheck certainly has no problem with it). And so the jacket isn’t my personal style, but it appears well-made and might appeal to others. But the owner of Regretsy has apparently decided that he or she has the final say on what is and is not acceptable on Etsy.

People of Walmart is supposedly a collection of nonstaged, nonPhotoshopped pictures of people at Walmart. Most of them are fat and with fat rolls hanging out. I’m in favor of dressing appropriately… but I guess I think it crosses some sort of line to take a picture of someone and, without their knowledge or consent, post it online for the sole purpose of making fun of them.

Both websites just rub me the completely wrong way.

Then I think about my favorite blog of all time, the “Blog” of “Unnecessary” quotation marks. Is that any different? It is still making fun, but the making fun is removed from the person – it’s making fun of bad grammar, not of people. It’s not “these people are so tasteless, can you believe it,” it’s more “isn’t this sign funny when you take into consideration what those quote marks mean?” Also, there’s no way to trace it back to where it came from – and purposefully so. Any identifying marks are blurred out.  Maybe I’m just hiding behind high-brow excuses, I don’t know. I still think they’re different.

Advertisements

3 responses to “Regretsy, People of Walmart, similar

  1. The people who run Regretsy have no other way to gain attention for themselves and they do crave attention. They have no talent to stand out in a crowd so they gain attention by attacking others, not caring what the result might be. Be careful. These are the very people who end up on a tall building with a shot gun yelling “look at me, look at me”.

    They interpreted “fair use” laws incorrectly and think they are safe behind that cloak. They are wrong. Fair use was created for educational purposes, not web sites that attack people. They are in violation of the copyright laws of the US.

  2. Well I stumbled across your article this morning. Having just been run through the Crap-Machine myself,{look up “Sandy Claws”} I agree with your assessment of the situation. And applaud your courage to speak out!

    I was not selected because of a nasty craft, but because I chose to sometimes grow my toenails freakishly long.

    While I’m pretty tough when it comes to personal criticism, having been called a freak all my life, but I wonder about the overall effect that this mob-mockery is having on the crafting community.

    Why not let the marketplace be the judge?
    If your stuff is crappy then people won’t buy it!Problem Magically Solved!

    Do we really need someone to step up and exert control over a free marketplace!

    I encourage people to research what they support and decide for themselves…
    I lost respect when I discovered that this is basically a copycat site{down to the way it claims the idea came about}that appears to be a well oiled marketing machine intended to promote a persons career. But hey it’s all for Charity!??

    Well, I don’t know about the rest of you, but I think I will decide whats crap and whats funny for myself! Annova Moon*Ae’M

    p.s. word to google today: Craftastrophe

  3. Pingback: A Response « Annova Moon's Blog

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s